The short answer: you can't pay for a better spot on the map. Google says it ranks local results on how well you match the search, how far you are from the person searching, and how well known you are. Fix your category, location and phone number, ask every past client for a Google review, reply to every review, and win the towns closest to you first.
Read the transcript
You've closed more deals. So why does the agent down the street show up first on Google Maps? Google says you can't pay to rank higher on the map. So what decides who shows up first? I'm Sam with Tin Roof Digital.
Not to be creepy, but I look at a lot of real estate agents Google profiles and why one shows up on the map and the other doesn't. Here's what Google itself says and what it looks like on real Google profiles. First, you can't buy your way onto the map. Google's own help page says there's no way to pay that can help you get a better page ranking. Ads are marked sponsored.
The regular map results, those are earned. Google says results mainly come from three things. How well you match the search, how far you are from the person that's searching, and three how well known you are. Let's take them one at a time because two of the three are in your hands. When a seller types this, Google looks for a profile that's a match.
Your category, your services, and your description. If your profile says agency or list services that you don't offer, you're the worst match. You're not going to be a good match. says businesses with complete and accurate information are the ones that will show up. That means every field filled in and filled in correctly.
Hours, phone, website, services, photos. Here's a quick test. Read your profile like you've never heard of you. Does it say plainly that you're a real estate agent? Which towns you work and how to reach you?
If you have to squint, so does Google. My second video in this series is the five setup fixes, and that's this part. Distance is a one thing you can't fake. Google looks at how far your profile is from the seller or person that's searching. But here's the part that agents miss.
Google only knows where your profile says that you are. Not where you actually sell. One agent that I graded in October had her area set at her brokerage's office, which is about 20 miles from the town that she actually sells in. To Google, she's 20 miles from her own sellers. Talk to your broker about the right address.
Or even better, set a service area with the towns that you actually serve or sell to. That's a 5 minute change and it's free. You can be honest with yourself about this one. If a seller is searching from a town across the county, an agent who's closer has an edge that you can't fully erase, no matter what you do. That's fine.
Win your own town first. Win your market. This is where the reviews come in. Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help your rankings in their own help page. The first 10 agents who have me grade their profiles have between zero Zero and 50 Google reviews.
The top profile on each map near them had between 26 and 768. That's the gap. And it's not that the agent down the street is better, more experienced or helps their customers in a different way. Google just has more proof about him. Proof is reviews, replies to those reviews, photos, posts, and other sites that mention you and link to you.
Every single one of those tells Google that people know who you are. Google also suggests replying to reviews. It shows people that you're paying attention and that you care. And it gives the next seller something to read besides just the stars. Think about what's the seller see in the first 10 seconds?
Three spots on the map, stars, review count, a photo and whether you're open. They haven't read a word yet. they've already started to decide. Here's one real profile I graded in October, name left off. It shows all three at once.
It was set up as a real estate agency instead of a real estate agent. And it listed homeowner's insurance and mortgages as some of its services. So Google is not sure what it is. Distance, it's sat in a town different than the one that he works in services. So Google was showing him to the wrong sellers.
Proof, zero Google reviews. top profile on the map in the town where his sat had 346, None of that is about how good he is at his job. three settings and a habit. The settings take one afternoon and they cost nothing. The reviews take months, but they start the day he asks.
hours. Google shows sellers whether you're open right now. Set hours that you actually answer the phone and keep those hours current. Photos, real ones, you, your sold signs, the houses and towns that you're working, the inside of a listing that you're proud of. A profile with no photo looks like nobody's home, like the lights are off, looks abandoned.
Post. Your profile lets you post updates. A new listing, a just sold, a quick note or update about the neighborhood that you sell in. Every week or two is plenty. shows Google and the seller that somebody's home.
So here's the week. Monday, fix your category and your location. Tuesday, make your phone number the same everywhere and check your website link. Click your phone number, make sure your phone rings. Click your website link, make sure it goes through.
Wednesday, text your last 10 clients for a Google review. They loved you, they made the biggest investment of their life with you. They'll do it, just ask them. Same words for everybody, no gifts tied to it. Then reply to every review that comes in and do it quickly.
When you get that email that says someone just left you a review, reply to it. A good review, send them a thank you, a bad review. For whatever reason it is, that's your chance to publicly show how you handle problems and how you take care of your customers. They're both equally powerful. run the wording, pass your broker first, keep your replies about the home and the work.
Never about who the home is perfect for. or anything that might get Google to flag your reply. Then do it again next week, stay consistent. This isn't a weekend project. Do the simple things consistently.
You don't control how far the seller is. You do control whether Google knows you sell there or not whether Google has proof that you take care of your customers and you do a great job. Do you want to see exactly where you're losing? agent x -ray? Put your google reviews next to the top five agents in your market.
Scores you out of a hundred and gives you the fixes in order. Usually back the same day, definitely back within 48 hours. No sales call, no obligation. The links in the description and in the pinned comment. If this helped, subscribe.
If it brought value to you, share it with your friends. If you disagree, let's talk about it in the comments. I'm open. I'm not perfect. Putting a new one of these out for agents every week, all free.
If you haven't asked for a review yet, start with your first 10 on my video. It's right here.
Can you pay to rank higher on Google Maps?
No. Google's help page on local ranking says there's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. You can run ads, and they'll show up above the map, but they're labeled Sponsored. The regular map spots underneath are earned.
That's good news if you're a solo agent. The agent on top didn't buy that spot, so you can earn one too.
What does Google say decides who shows up first?
Google says local results come mainly from three things:
- Match. How well your profile matches what the seller typed.
- Distance. How far your profile is from the person searching.
- How well known you are. Google calls it prominence. Reviews, ratings and other sites that mention and link to you all feed it.
Two of the three are in your hands. Here they are one at a time.
1. Do you match the search?
When a seller types "real estate agent near me," Google looks for profiles that match. That's your category, your services and your description. If your profile is set up as an agency when you're an agent, or lists services you don't offer, you're a worse match.
Google also says businesses with complete and accurate information are more likely to show up. Fill in every field, and fill it in right: hours, phone, website, services and photos.
A quick test: read your profile like you've never heard of you. Does it say plainly that you're a real estate agent, which towns you work, and how to reach you? If you have to squint, so does Google.
2. How far away are you?
Distance is the one you can't fake. But here's the part agents miss: Google only knows where your profile says you are, not where you actually sell.
One agent I graded in October had her profile sitting at her brokerage's office, about 20 miles from the town she sells in. To Google, she's 20 miles from her own sellers. Talk to your broker about the right address, or set a service area with the towns you actually work. That's a five minute change.
Be honest with yourself here, too. If a seller is searching from a town across the county, the agent who's closer has an edge you can't fully erase. That's fine. Win your own towns first.
3. How well known are you?
This is where reviews come in. Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking. The first 10 agents who asked me to grade their profile had between 0 and 50 Google reviews. The top profile on the map near each of them had between 26 and 768.
That's the gap. It's not that the agent down the street is better at the job. Google just has more proof about him. Proof is reviews, replies to those reviews, photos, posts, and other sites that mention you and link to you.
And think about the first 10 seconds. A seller sees three spots on the map, stars, a review count, a photo and whether you're open. They haven't read a word yet, and they've already started to decide.
What did the top 20 in Indianapolis and Chicago have in common?
On October 20, I searched "real estate agent" plus the city on Google Maps and took the first 10 profiles in Indianapolis and in Chicago. For each one I wrote down the stars, total reviews, new reviews this year and how many recent reviews got a reply. No names. It's one day in two cities, so treat it as a snapshot, and the map changes depending on where you search from.
I walk through the whole check in this video.
- A lot of them aren't agents. 4 of the 10 in Indianapolis and 5 of the 10 in Chicago were brokerage offices. A solo agent is up against teams and their own office, not just the agent down the street.
- Stars barely separate anybody. 18 of the 20 had 4.8 stars or better. One Chicago office had a 4.2 and still made the top 10.
- The review bar depends on your market. The fewest reviews in either top 10 was 42. In a small town I checked the same day, the top agent on the map had 20.
- More reviews didn't mean higher. The profile with the most reviews in Chicago, 756, was tenth. Chicago's number one went about two years without a new review.
- The top six all answer their reviews. Every top three profile in both cities replied to at least 8 out of 10 of their recent reviews, had at least 121 reviews, and 5 of the 6 got at least 18 new reviews this year.
The honest part: four profiles lower on the list checked all those boxes too. In a big city, reviews and replies are the ticket in, not the trophy. My guess is an office with a big name can coast for a while. A solo agent probably can't. Your name isn't on a building yet.
Should you put your city in your business name?
Three of the 10 in Indianapolis had the word Indianapolis tacked onto the profile name. Google's guidelines say your profile name should be your real business name, and extra words like a city can get a profile suspended. If the city isn't truly part of your business name, leave it out and put your towns in your description and service area.
What to do this week
- Monday: fix your category and your location.
- Tuesday: make your phone number the same everywhere, then tap it and tap your website link to make sure both work.
- Wednesday: text your last 10 closed clients for a Google review. Same words for everybody, no gifts tied to it.
- Every day: reply to every review that comes in. Keep replies about the home and the work, never about who a home is perfect for.
- Every week or two: post on your profile. A new listing, a just sold, a quick note about a street you know.
Run your wording past your broker first. Then do it again next week. This isn't a weekend project. It's a habit.
Free tools that go with this
Questions agents ask about Google Maps
Can a real estate agent pay to rank higher on Google Maps?
No. Google's own help page says there's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking. Ads can show up above the map, but they're labeled Sponsored. The regular map spots are earned.
What does Google say decides who shows up on the map?
Google says local results come mainly from three things: relevance, which is how well your profile matches the search, distance from the person searching, and prominence, which is how well known you are. Reviews, positive ratings and links from other sites feed prominence.
Do more Google reviews mean you rank first?
Not by themselves. In our October 20 check of Indianapolis and Chicago, the profile with the most reviews in Chicago, 756, ranked tenth on the map. Every top 20 profile had at least 42 reviews, so reviews got them in the door, but they didn't decide the order on their own.
Should I add my city to my Google business name?
Only if the city is truly part of your business name. Google's guidelines say the name on your profile should match your real business name, and extra words like a city can get a profile suspended. Say which towns you serve in your description and service area instead.
Where should a real estate agent's Google profile be located?
Google only knows where your profile says you are. If it sits at a brokerage office 20 miles from where you sell, Google treats you as 20 miles from those sellers. Talk to your broker about the right address, or set a service area with the towns you actually work.
Free Real Estate X-Ray
See exactly where you're losing on the map
Send me your name and brokerage. I'll line you up against the top 5 agents near you: your Google reviews next to theirs, your profile, listings, Facebook and website, scored out of 100 with the fixes in order. Anything you change should still go past your broker and fair housing rules first.
Rather not chase reviews yourself? If you’ve closed 10 or more homes, I’ll do the asking for you, from your desk, in your name. It starts with the free X-Ray.
Built by hand from public pages. Back to you in 48 hours, and there's no sales call. No results guarantee: Google decides the map.

