Tin Roof field notes / Google reviews

How to reply to Google reviews.
Twenty replies you can copy.

Your reply isn't really for the person who left the review. It's for the next customer reading it before they decide who to call. Here's how to reply, what Google checks, a four part formula that fits any review, and twenty replies to steal.

The short answer: reply to every review, good and bad. Use their first name, thank them for one specific thing, add one useful line, and sign it with your name. Keep it short. On a bad one, stay calm, own what's fair and give them a direct way to reach you. Never argue, never share their private details, and never offer a deal in a reply.

Sam Harrington, 1:41. Also on YouTube.

Why reply to Google reviews at all?

Because people read them. Your reply sits right under the review, and the next customer reads both before they pick up the phone.

A profile where every review has a short, real answer says somebody's paying attention. A profile with forty reviews and zero replies says nobody's home.

When I checked the first 10 real estate profiles on Google Maps in Indianapolis and in Chicago on October 20, eighteen of the twenty had 4.8 stars or better. Stars barely separated anybody. What separated them was how many reviews they had, how recent they were, and whether anyone replied.

Google's own help page says the reviewer gets a notification when you reply. That's a nice moment for a happy customer, and on a bad review it's your best shot at turning it around.

How do you reply to a Google review?

Your profile has to be verified first. Then, on a computer:

  1. Go to business.google.com and sign in.
  2. Select Read reviews.
  3. Next to the review, select the Reply icon.
  4. Type your reply and select Reply.

On your phone, searching your business name while you're signed in usually brings up your profile with the same review list and reply option.

A few things Google says about what happens next:

  • Replies get checked first. Google reviews them against its content policies. That usually takes up to 10 minutes, but Google says it can take up to 30 days. If one isn't approved, you'll be asked to edit it.
  • Replies post as your business, not your personal name. That's why signing it with your first name helps.
  • You can edit or delete a reply later. In Read reviews, use the Edit icon and select Update, or the Delete icon.
  • The customer can still change their review after you reply. If they do, the review's date updates.

The four part reply that works for almost any review

  1. Their first name. Only if they used it on the review.
  2. Thanks for one specific thing. Pull a detail from what they wrote. "Thanks for the review" alone is the generic reply Google's own tips tell you to avoid.
  3. One useful line. An update, an answer to a question they raised, or a tip for the next customer.
  4. Your name. A real person signing it goes a long way.

Two to four sentences. That's it. Google's tips say keep replies brief and conversational, not promotional, and don't use replies to offer deals.

Replies for five star reviews

Swap in your own details. Brackets are the parts to change.

1. The everyday job

Thanks, [NAME]. That [JOB] had a tricky [DETAIL], so I'm glad it came out the way you wanted. Call us anytime. [YOUR NAME]

2. They mentioned someone on your team

Thank you, [NAME]. I'll make sure [TEAM MEMBER] sees this. [HE/SHE] takes a lot of pride in leaving a place cleaner than we found it. [YOUR NAME]

3. A repeat customer

[NAME], three jobs in and you still keep calling us. That means a lot. Thanks for trusting us again. [YOUR NAME]

4. Real estate closing

Congratulations again, [NAME]. That [CHALLENGE, like the appraisal or the inspection] had us all sweating for a minute. Enjoy the new place. [YOUR NAME]

5. Campground, rental or a visit

Thanks, [NAME]. Glad the [SITE, CABIN, LESSON] worked out and the weather cooperated. Hope to see you back next season. [YOUR NAME]

Replies for star only reviews (no words)

Keep these short. You don't know much, so don't pretend to.

6.

Thank you, [NAME]. We appreciate you taking a second to rate us. [YOUR NAME]

7.

Thanks for the five stars, [NAME]. If you ever need anything else, you know where to find us. [YOUR NAME]

8. A low rating with no words

[NAME], I'm sorry it wasn't a better experience. I couldn't find what went wrong from here, and I'd like to. Would you call me at [PHONE]? [YOUR NAME]

Replies for four star and mixed reviews

These are the most useful reviews you'll get. Answer the gripe directly. The next customer is wondering about the same thing.

9. Happy, but it ran long

Thanks, [NAME]. You're right, we ran [TWO DAYS] past what I told you, and I should have called you sooner when the [REASON] held us up. Glad you love how it turned out. [YOUR NAME]

10. Happy, but hard to reach

Thanks for the honest review, [NAME]. Fair point on the callbacks. We've since [CHANGE, like set up a text line or added office hours] so that doesn't happen again. [YOUR NAME]

11. Happy, but price came up

Thanks, [NAME]. I appreciate you saying it. We'd rather do it once and do it right, and I'm glad the [RESULT] shows that. [YOUR NAME]

12. Three stars, a little of everything

[NAME], thanks for taking the time to write all that out. The [GOOD PART] is good to hear. The [PROBLEM] isn't how we want it to go. I'd like to hear more if you're open to a call: [PHONE]. [YOUR NAME]

Replies for one and two star reviews

Read it, walk away, come back in an hour. Then answer. Google's tips for negative reviews: apologize where it's appropriate, make it personal, protect the reviewer's privacy, explain what you can and can't do, and respond promptly.

13. You messed up

[NAME], you're right, and I'm sorry. We didn't [WHAT WENT WRONG], and that's on us. I'd like to make it right. Please call me directly at [PHONE]. [YOUR NAME]

14. You disagree with how they tell it

[NAME], I'm sorry you're frustrated. I see this one a little differently, and I'd rather talk it through than go back and forth here. My direct line is [PHONE]. [YOUR NAME]

15. Something you can't do

[NAME], I understand why that was disappointing. We aren't able to [THING, like work in that county or take that job size], and I should have made that clearer up front. I'm sorry for the wasted time. [YOUR NAME]

16. They're upset about a policy

Thanks for the feedback, [NAME]. Our [POLICY] is there because [ONE PLAIN REASON], and I know it isn't convenient for everybody. If there's something we can work out, call me at [PHONE]. [YOUR NAME]

17. You already fixed it

[NAME], thank you for giving us the chance to come back out. I'm glad we got the [PROBLEM] sorted, and I'm sorry it took two trips. [YOUR NAME]

Notice what's missing: no names of anyone else involved, no details about their job they didn't share, no "as you know, you signed a contract that says." If you sell insurance, handle money or work in anything regulated, keep every detail of their account out of it and check with your carrier, broker or compliance person on what you can say.

Replies for reviews you can't place

Report it first if it breaks Google's rules. Here's how to report a fake Google review. While Google looks at it, a calm reply tells the next customer what's going on without picking a fight.

18. Not your customer

Hi [NAME]. We take every review seriously, and I can't find a record of working with you under this name. If we did, please call me at [PHONE] so I can look into it. [YOUR NAME]

19. Wrong business

Hi [NAME]. I think this may be meant for a different company. We don't [SERVICE THEY DESCRIBED]. If I'm wrong, call me at [PHONE] and I'll make it right. [YOUR NAME]

20. A competitor, or worse

We've reported this review to Google because we have no record of this person as a customer. Anyone with a question about our work can reach me directly at [PHONE]. [YOUR NAME]

Don't accuse anybody of anything you can't back up. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews prohibits false accusations about a reviewer and intimidation to get a review changed. The FTC's questions and answers cover it.

A few habits that make this easy

  • Reply within a day or two. Faster is better for the bad ones. The customer is still around and still listening.
  • Catch up on the old ones. If you've got a stack with no replies, start with the newest twenty and work back.
  • Save your favorite replies. Keep five or six in a note on your phone and change the details each time. A copy and paste with no detail looks like a copy and paste.
  • AI is fine for a first draft. Paste the review in, ask for two short options, then add one real detail only you'd know. If you can't add one, it's not done.
  • Keep the reviews coming. Replies matter more when there's a steady stream. Here's how to ask for a Google review and where to find your review link.

Free tools that go with this

Questions owners ask about replying to reviews

How do I reply to a Google review?

Your profile has to be verified first. On a computer, go to business.google.com, select Read reviews, select the Reply icon next to the review, type your reply and select Reply.

Does the customer see my reply?

Yes. Google notifies the reviewer when you reply, and approved replies show publicly under the review as coming from your business.

Why isn't my reply showing up?

Google checks replies against its content policies first. Google says that usually takes up to 10 minutes but can take up to 30 days. If a reply isn't approved, you'll be asked to edit it.

Should I reply to every Google review?

Yes, good and bad. Keep it short, use their first name and one real detail, and skip the generic thank you.

What should I say to a bad Google review?

Stay calm and short. Apologize where it's fair, say what you can and can't do, keep their private details out of it, and give them a way to reach you directly.

Can I offer a discount in my reply?

Google's tips say to keep replies conversational, not promotional, and not to use replies to offer deals.

Can I edit or delete my reply later?

Yes. In Read reviews, select the Edit icon under your reply to change it and select Update, or select the Delete icon to remove it.

Free Google X-Ray

See how your reviews stack up nearby

Send me your business name and town. I'll line you up against the top 5 businesses like yours nearby: your Google reviews next to theirs and your profile, scored out of 100 with the fixes in order. It's yours to keep.

Get my free Google X-Ray

Built from public pages. Back to you within 48 hours, and there's no sales call. No results guarantee: Google decides the map.

Let's talk
Tin Roof Digital

A direct line to Sam

What are you
working toward?

A better website, stronger content, or more of the right inquiries. Tell us where you want to start.

A personal reply within one business day. No mailing list.
By sending, you agree we can reply about your request. Privacy policy.

Rather talk it through?574.350.9712sam@tinroofdigital.com